5.0 on Google · 66 reviews Review us on Google (619) 370-5227
King Corso
Kennel
  1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. FCI vs OFA Hip and Elbow Scores: HD-A, ED-0 Explained
Comparisons

FCI vs OFA Hip and Elbow Scores: HD-A, ED-0 Explained

When a Cane Corso breeder says a dog is “HD-A, ED-0,” and another says “OFA Good, elbows Normal,” they are describing the same kind of x-ray result in two different languages. This guide translates between them, shows where the translation is exact and where it is only approximate, and gives you the questions that separate a real health certificate from a sales line.

Short answer: HD-A is the top FCI hip grade (no signs of hip dysplasia) and ED-0 is the top elbow grade (normal elbow). On OFA’s own comparison chart, HD-A lines up with Excellent (A-1) or Good (A-2) hips, and ED-0 lines up with an OFA “Normal” elbow. Both systems are legitimate. What matters is the certificate behind the letters.

  • FCI-style scores (HD/ED letters and numbers) are what you’ll see on dogs from Europe, South America and other FCI countries, including imported breeding dogs.
  • OFA grades (Excellent/Good/Fair, Normal elbows) are what you’ll see on dogs x-rayed in the US and Canada, and they come with a public, searchable OFA number.

What does HD-A / ED-0 mean on a Cane Corso?

HD-A means the dog’s hips were x-rayed and graded “A,” the best of five FCI grades, summarized in a 2007 veterinary review as “No signs of Hip Dysplasia.” ED-0 means the elbows were graded 0, a “normal elbow joint” with no evidence of arthrosis, under the grading scheme of the International Elbow Working Group (IEWG).

The FCI hip scale runs from A to E. The FCI’s own hip dysplasia classification, approved in November 2022, defines each grade by what the x-ray shows. For grade A, the femoral head is “well centred in the acetabulum,” the joint space is “narrow and even,” and “no signs of osteoarthritic changes are present.”

The short labels most people use come from a 2007 review in the European Journal of Companion Animal Practice by Professor Mark Flückiger of the Zurich dysplasia committee. In his summary, grade A is “No signs of Hip Dysplasia,” B is “Near normal hip joints,” C is “Mild hip dysplasia,” D is “Moderate hip dysplasia” and E is “Severe Hip Dysplasia.” The final grade is based on the worse of the two hips, so an HD-A dog has two good hips, not one good hip and one average one.

Some countries split each letter in two (A1 and A2, B1 and B2 and so on). If you see “A1” or “A2,” both sit inside grade A.

The elbow scale runs from 0 to 3. A University of Giessen summary of the IEWG protocol, presented at the 2014 WSAVA World Congress, defines grade 0 as “Normal elbow joint” with “No evidence of incongruency, sclerosis or arthrosis.” Grade 1 is “osteophytes < 2 mm high,” grade 2 is “osteophytes of 2–5 mm high” and grade 3 is “osteophytes of > 5 mm high.” Some countries also use a “borderline” score between 0 and 1.

What do OFA hip grades mean?

OFA hip grades sort dogs into three normal grades (Excellent, Good, Fair), one in-between grade (Borderline) and three dysplastic grades (Mild, Moderate, Severe). The Orthopedic Foundation for Animals describes them this way:

  • Excellent: “Superior conformation; there is a deep-seated ball (femoral head) that fits tightly into a well-formed socket.”
  • Good: “Slightly less than superior but a well-formed congruent hip joint is visualized.”
  • Fair: “Minor irregularities; the hip joint is wider than a good hip.”
  • Borderline: “Not clear. Usually more incongruency present than what occurs in a fair.”
  • Mild: “Significant subluxation present where the ball is partially out of the socket causing an increased joint space.”
  • Moderate: “The ball is barely seated into a shallow socket.”
  • Severe: “Marked evidence that hip dysplasia exists.”

Excellent, Good and Fair are all passing grades. A dog with any of the three gets an OFA number. OFA says hip x-rays of dogs 24 months or older are “independently evaluated by three randomly selected, board-certified veterinary radiologists,” and that the final grade is a consensus of those three readings.

What do OFA elbow results mean?

OFA does not grade normal elbows at all. A normal elbow is simply “Normal”; the grades exist only for abnormal joints. In OFA’s words, “there are no grades for a radiographically normal elbow.”

The OFA elbow page defines the abnormal grades by the size of the bony change along the anconeal process: Grade I is “less than 2mm,” Grade II is “2-5 mm” plus some subchondral bone changes, and Grade III is “greater than 5 mm” with well-developed degenerative joint disease. Those millimeter thresholds match the IEWG grades 1 to 3, which is why the elbow comparison is close to one-to-one.

How do FCI and OFA hip grades compare?

They compare closely but not perfectly, because the two systems were built differently. OFA publishes its own comparison chart of international hip registries, and the same list is reprinted in Flückiger’s 2007 review as a list provided by OFA. It lines the grades up like this:

OFA hip grade FCI hip grade What it means
Excellent A (A1) Normal, best conformation
Good A (A2) Normal
Fair B (B1) Normal or near normal
Borderline B (B2) Unclear; OFA recommends a re-x-ray
Mild C Mild hip dysplasia
Moderate D Moderate hip dysplasia
Severe E Severe hip dysplasia

Sources: OFA hip international ratings matrix (ofa.org); Flückiger M., “Scoring radiographs for canine Hip Dysplasia: The big three organisations in the world,” EJCAP 2007 (Table 4, list provided by OFA). The “what it means” column is our plain-English summary.

Flückiger’s paper also prints a second, more detailed comparison (its Table 3) that does not match exactly: it puts OFA Good across A2 and B1, and OFA Fair at B2. That disagreement is useful information. It tells you the conversion is a translation, not an equation. The safe reading is this: HD-A corresponds to OFA Excellent or Good in both tables. HD-B is the gray zone: OFA’s chart puts it at Fair to Borderline, while Flückiger’s Table 3 puts it nearer Good to Fair. On OFA’s chart, HD-C, D and E line up with OFA’s dysplastic grades (Mild, Moderate, Severe).

Side by side: FCI-style screening vs OFA

FCI / IEWG style OFA
Where it’s used FCI member countries (most of Europe, plus parts of South America and Asia) United States and Canada
Minimum age, hips 1 year for most breeds; 18 months for large and giant breeds 24 months or older for an official grade; preliminary screens from 4 to 23 months
Minimum age, elbows Around 12 months in published Swedish screening data 2 years to certify a normal elbow; preliminaries accepted
Hip scale A, B, C, D, E (A = no signs of dysplasia) Excellent, Good, Fair, Borderline, Mild, Moderate, Severe
Passing hips A and B are normal or near normal; D and E are barred from breeding in most countries, and C may carry restrictions Excellent, Good, Fair
Elbow scale ED 0, (borderline), 1, 2, 3 Normal, Grade I, II, III
Best elbow result ED-0 Normal
Who reads the x-ray A specialized veterinarian approved by the national kennel club or breed club; usually a single scrutineer Three board-certified radiologists, consensus grade
How you verify it The official certificate or the national kennel club’s record OFA number, searchable on ofa.org

Sources: FCI Requirements for Official Hip Dysplasia Screening (2022 revision); Flückiger 2007 (FCI and OFA scoring modes); ofa.org hip and elbow pages; Tellhelm et al., WSAVA 2014 (IEWG grades); Bergström et al., Frontiers in Veterinary Science 2020 (elbow screening age in Sweden).

Is an FCI hip score less reliable than an OFA score?

It can be, depending on who read the x-ray. The published criticism is worth knowing, and so is what has changed since.

Writing in 2007, Flückiger, a specialist in veterinary diagnostic imaging (Dipl. ECVDI), said that the FCI “accepts scores made by anyone considering himself expert” and that the training of scrutineers “vary enormously,” from certified veterinary radiologists to, occasionally, lay people. He also wrote that OFA and BVA/KC graders are experts whose gradings “are undisputed,” that “the same is true” for scrutineers in many western and northern European countries, and that in some other countries scores “may differ markedly from reality.”

The FCI’s current requirements for official hip dysplasia screening, revised in November 2022, are tighter on paper. They say radiographs “should be interpreted and scored by a specialized veterinarian approved by the national kennel club and/or the breed club,” require the dog to be identified by microchip (or a legible tattoo where allowed), and tell each member country to provide an appeal procedure. The reader is still chosen country by country.

So an HD-A from a well-run national scheme is strong evidence of good hips, in the same range as an OFA Excellent or Good. An HD-A with no certificate, no named reader and no age on the x-ray carries much less. The fix is simple: ask to see the paper.

Why does the age at x-ray matter?

Hip dysplasia is progressive, so an x-ray of an older dog tells you more than an x-ray of a young one. OFA’s grade descriptions, as reproduced in Flückiger’s paper, note that “the older the dog, the more accurate the diagnosis,” and Flückiger’s paper says FCI’s grading is built around dogs between 1 and 2 years old.

OFA gives a final hip rating only to dogs 24 months or older, which is why a “preliminary” OFA result is not the same as a certification. The FCI’s requirements set the minimum age for official hip x-rays at “one (1) year for most dog breeds and 18 months for large and giant breeds.” The FCI standard describes the Cane Corso as “medium to large sized,” so for an imported dog it is fair to ask which minimum the scoring country applied. When a breeder quotes a score, ask how old the dog was when it was taken.

Can two dogs with perfect hips produce a puppy with hip dysplasia?

Yes. Good parental scores lower the odds; they don’t make a guarantee. Flückiger writes that radiographs “do not precisely reflect the genetic make up of a dog itself nor the risk for passing CHD to the offspring.”

Hip dysplasia is hereditary, but an x-ray score is an imperfect guide to the genes behind it. The same paper puts the average heritability of hip scores under the FCI system at about 30%, “reaching 50% in well designed studies.” In plain terms: screening parents shifts the odds in your puppy’s favor without removing the risk. Ask your vet about growth, weight and exercise for a large-breed puppy.

Elbow dysplasia works similarly. OFA calls it “an inherited polygenic disease” and lists the separate problems it covers: fragmented coronoid process (FCP), osteochondritis (OCD) and ununited anconeal process (UAP).

How do you read an OFA number?

An OFA number packs the breed, result, age and identification into one string. OFA’s own example is LR-100E24M-C-PI:

  • LR is the breed code (Labrador Retriever in the example).
  • 100 is the dog’s sequence number among normal dogs of that breed.
  • E is the grade: “E = Excellent, other normal phenotypes include G (Good) and F (Fair).”
  • 24 is the age in months when the x-ray was taken.
  • M is the sex (male).
  • C means chemical restraint was used during the x-ray.
  • PI means the dog is permanently identified by tattoo or microchip. VPI means a vet verified that ID, and NOPI means no permanent ID.

The OFA guide to reading numbers covers the other formats. You can search any certified dog by name or number on ofa.org.

Which is better for a Cane Corso buyer: FCI or OFA scores?

Neither is better in principle; a properly read x-ray is a properly read x-ray. What you want is a documented result from a recognized scheme, on both parents, taken at a sensible age.

The scheme you’ll see usually depends on where the dog was screened. Flückiger describes OFA as “exclusively representing the USA and Canada,” while FCI-style grading is used by its member kennel clubs across Europe, South America and Asia. So a kennel with imported parents will often show FCI letters, and that’s normal.

The Cane Corso Association of America’s judges’ manual and the AKC standard describe the breed’s structure in detail, but neither one replaces x-rays. Structure you can see; hips and elbows you can’t.

What should you ask any Cane Corso breeder about hip and elbow scores?

Ask these, and expect clear answers with documents:

  1. Which scheme scored the hips and elbows? OFA, a national FCI kennel club scheme, or something else?
  2. Can I see the certificates for both parents? Not a photo of a dog with “HD-A” typed on it; the actual document with the dog’s name and ID.
  3. How old was each dog at the x-ray? FCI rules set a minimum of 1 year for most breeds and 18 months for large and giant breeds; OFA certifies at 24 months or older.
  4. Is the dog microchipped or tattooed, and does the ID match the certificate?
  5. What about the grandparents and siblings? A line with consistently good results tells you more than one good dog.
  6. Are elbows scored too? Hips alone are half the picture.

Our longer list of questions to ask a Cane Corso breeder and the breeder red flags post cover the rest of the conversation.

How Aston uses hip and elbow scores at King Corso Kennel

Aston’s interest in hip and elbow scores is personal. In 2014 he bought a male and a female Cane Corso from a backyard breeder to protect his property. The male developed hip dysplasia and had trouble getting up. The female had cherry eye, joint problems and knee dysplasia. The surgeries cost more than the dogs, and both needed long-term pain management.

That experience is why he studied genetics and pedigrees and built his program on European bloodlines with an emphasis on health, structure and temperament. His breeding dogs with published scores are all HD-A / ED-0: Giulio Caesar (from a grand champion lineage in Bosnia with original Italian genetics), Yunis King Corso and Queen Corso (both imported from Serbia), Roxy II King Corso (Argentinian bloodline) and Kayla King Corso (bred here). Gloria King Corso, a black female, has no published scores, and we don’t claim any for her.

You can see the dogs on our dogs page and read how we approach screening on our health testing page. If you’d like to see a certificate for a specific parent, ask; that’s exactly the question this article tells you to ask everyone, us included.

For the bigger picture on joints, see our Cane Corso hip dysplasia guide, the guide to Cane Corso health problems, and how bloodlines differ in European vs American Cane Corso. When you’re ready to talk about a litter, visit available puppies or call (619) 370-5227.

Comparing breeds? See all our Cane Corso comparisons side by side.

Frequently asked questions

Is HD-A better than OFA Excellent?

No. They sit in the same range. In OFA’s own comparison chart, OFA Excellent corresponds to FCI A1 and OFA Good to FCI A2, so an HD-A dog sits in the Excellent-to-Good range. The more useful question is who read the x-ray and at what age. A certificate from a recognized national scheme or OFA, on a dog over the minimum age, matters more than which letter system was used.

What does ED-1 mean, and is it a deal-breaker?

ED-1 means mild elbow arthrosis, with bony changes (osteophytes) under 2 mm high under the IEWG scheme. It is not a normal elbow. As a buyer, know that ED-0 is the normal score, ask which breeding rules the breeder’s club applies to ED-1 dogs, and ask why a parent with ED-1 was chosen.

Can a puppy be hip scored?

Not officially. FCI rules set the minimum age at 1 year for most breeds and 18 months for large and giant breeds, and OFA gives a final grade only at 24 months or older. OFA does offer preliminary screenings for dogs between 4 and 23 months, but a preliminary result is not a final rating. For a puppy, the best evidence you have is the parents’ and grandparents’ certified scores.

What is a “borderline” hip or elbow result?

Borderline means the reader couldn’t call the joint clearly normal or clearly dysplastic. On OFA hips it sits between Fair and Mild, and OFA’s descriptions recommend repeating the x-ray later, usually after about six months. Some elbow schemes also use a borderline score between ED-0 and ED-1. Treat a borderline parent as an open question, not a pass.

Do OFA and FCI use the same x-ray?

They use the same standard hip view: the dog on its back with the hind legs extended and parallel. That’s why the results can be compared at all. FCI rules call for the dog to be sedated or anesthetized, while an OFA number records whether chemical restraint was used. The bigger differences are in how the image is graded, how many people read it, and the minimum age.

Can I look up a European dog’s HD-A score online?

Sometimes. OFA results are searchable on ofa.org. Under the FCI system, Flückiger notes, how results are published depends on the rules of each breed club, so there isn’t one place to look. For an imported dog, ask the breeder for the original certificate, check that the microchip number matches, and ask which country’s scheme issued it.

Should a breeder test anything besides hips and elbows?

Hips and elbows are the core orthopedic screens for a large breed, but they aren’t the whole picture. Ask about eyes and heart screening and about any DNA tests the breeder runs, and ask your vet which tests make sense for the line you’re considering. Our health problems guide lists the conditions worth discussing.

Inquire about a puppy

Answer four quick questions and Aston will call you back about the right litter for your family. It takes under a minute.

Find your King Corso puppy

Step 1 of 4
What do you want your Cane Corso for?
Male or female?

Preferred colour (pick any)

When would you like your puppy?
Where should Aston call you?

We only use your number to talk to you about a puppy.

Thank you,

Aston will call you to talk about upcoming litters. Can't wait? Call or text now.

(619) 370-5227
Call Us